AAO research
A guitarist, songwriter, and producer relied on gold and platinum plaques, but the AAO could not connect the sales to him; later judging and pay evidence postdated filing.
Decision snapshot
Decision detail | Source-backed value |
|---|---|
Decision ID | Apr082010_01B2203 |
Disposition stated in the source | The AAO dismissed the appeal after finding no major award or three criteria and no sustained acclaim. It rejected the claimed music-sale, judging, publication, role, and compensation evidence on this record. |
Source location |
The petitioner was a guitarist, songwriter, and producer
The petition, filed August 15, 2007, concerned a musician who worked on recordings and television music. Counsel sought comparable-evidence treatment for reference letters, but the AAO found the record addressed the regulatory criteria and did not show why they were inapplicable. The appeal was dismissed.
Source: Apr082010_01B2203 page 2; Apr082010_01B2203 page 4; Apr082010_01B2203 page 15; Apr082010_01B2203 page 17; Apr082010_01B2203 page 18.
Gold and platinum plaques showed sales, not an award received by the petitioner
The petitioner agreed the record plaques were evidence of commercial success rather than awards. The album credits did not identify him among collaborators on Nelly Furtado’s album or among contributors to Delta Goodrem’s album. The AAO therefore found no basis to attribute the sales to his work or treat the plaques as his prizes for excellence.
Source: Apr082010_01B2203 page 5; Apr082010_01B2203 page 8; Apr082010_01B2203 page 14.
ASCAP membership lacked evidence of achievement-based admission
A letter confirmed ASCAP membership, but the record contained no bylaws or admission criteria showing that outstanding achievement judged by recognized experts was required.
Source: Apr082010_01B2203 page 5.
Articles covered Nelly Furtado and her concert, not the petitioner
Two Rolling Stone web articles mentioned the petitioner among band members, while focusing on Nelly Furtado and her concert. The record also lacked readership evidence establishing the websites as major media. The AAO found these articles insufficient for the criterion.
Source: Apr082010_01B2203 page 6.
The judging evidence postdated filing and involved student auditions
A July 2008 letter described the petitioner judging students at an Irvine Music Academy School of Rock audition. The petition had been filed in August 2007, so the event occurred too late. The AAO also stated that judging the work of students who had not entered the field did not establish the criterion in this case.
Source: Apr082010_01B2203 page 6; Apr082010_01B2203 page 7.
Letters and credits did not establish original contributions of major significance
The record described guitar, production, and songwriting work with successful artists, but letters did not document how the petitioner’s contributions influenced the field. Album credits and sales were incomplete or attributed primarily to featured vocalists; future projects and anticipated success could not establish eligibility at filing. The AAO found no demonstrated field-wide impact.
Source: Apr082010_01B2203 page 7; Apr082010_01B2203 page 8; Apr082010_01B2203 page 9; Apr082010_01B2203 page 10; Apr082010_01B2203 page 11; Apr082010_01B2203 page 12.
Brief production work and endorsements did not establish leading or critical roles
The petitioner composed theme music and jingles for television segments and endorsed Godin guitars. The AAO found no evidence that these roles were critical to the shows or companies, distinguished him from other contributors, or established the organizations’ reputation. A 2007 agreement postdated filing.
Source: Apr082010_01B2203 page 12; Apr082010_01B2203 page 13.
Compensation figures lacked a valid comparison or filing-date history
The record included a $3,000 agreement for a theme song and jingles and pre-filing ASCAP statements. Later royalties, a $600-per-composition agreement, and $35,000 in 2008 invoices postdated filing. The AAO found no comparison showing the earlier compensation was high relative to others in the field or complete earnings history.
Source: Apr082010_01B2203 page 13; Apr082010_01B2203 page 15.
The AAO found no qualifying threshold and no overall sustained acclaim
The AAO concluded there was no major internationally recognized award or evidence under at least three criteria. It found commercial sales not attributable to the petitioner, relied on a record of support roles alongside prominent artists, and concluded that the total evidence did not show sustained acclaim or top-of-field standing. Prior O-1 approvals did not compel EB-1A approval.
Source: Apr082010_01B2203 page 15; Apr082010_01B2203 page 16; Apr082010_01B2203 page 17; Apr082010_01B2203 page 18.
Current framework and related reading
EB-1A Original Contributions: Evidence of Major Significance
EB-1A Initial Evidence: Three of Ten Criteria and the Award Route
The decisions above are non-precedent assessments of particular records. Historical reasoning is identified as historical; consult current guidance for the present framework.