AAO research

EB-1A Judging Evidence: Actual Evaluation of Others’ Work

EB-1A Judging Evidence: Actual Evaluation of Others’ Work

Review EB-1A judging evidence, completed peer review, panels, field relevance, and the difference between an invitation and actual participation.

The criterion concerns an activity, not three job categories

The judging category concerns participation, individually or on a panel, in evaluating the work of others in the same or an allied field of specialization. It is not limited to three specified professions.

The previous guide invented a restrictive list of qualifying jobs and additional universal requirements. This version replaces those statements with the regulation and USCIS guidance.

Show that the judging happened

USCIS expressly distinguishes an invitation from actual participation. For journal peer review, its example pairs the review request with confirmation that the review was completed. Records should connect the person to the evaluation performed.

Other examples in current guidance include review of conference papers or abstracts, service on a dissertation committee that makes the final doctoral-degree judgment, and review of government research funding proposals. These are examples, not the only possible judging activities.

Explain the work and its field

Identify what was evaluated, who performed the evaluation, and how the subject relates to the person’s field or an allied field. An invitation, title, or employment contract can supply context, but the record should establish the actual judging activity.

Routine supervision or a job title should not simply be relabelled judging without explaining the work evaluated and the relevant field. Conversely, the regulation does not impose the old guide’s blanket requirements for separate awards, certificates of judging skill, or a paid role.

Read the evidence at both stages

For the initial category, address its actual wording. The caliber and significance of judging activity can also bear on the overall assessment. Showing one completed review is not an approval prediction. Read the threshold guide to distinguish a criterion from the whole petition.

Primary sources

USCIS Policy Manual, Volume 6, Part F, Chapter 2, Section B explains the initial criteria and final merits assessment.

8 CFR 204.5(h) provides the regulation. These official sources were checked on October 17, 2026.