AAO research
Distinguish an AAO appeal from motions to reopen or reconsider, and find current USCIS Form I-290B filing instructions.
Identify the proceeding before reading the outcome
An AAO appeal reviews a challenged USCIS decision. A motion asks the office with jurisdiction to reopen or reconsider a decision. A procedural rejection or summary dismissal should not be described as an appellate approval or as a finding that the original petition contained no evidence.
The previous guide named Form EOIR-18, gave an unreliable fee and deadline, and confused reconsideration with new evidence. Those statements have been removed. Use the applicable decision notice and current USCIS instructions for the filing involved.
Use the appropriate current instructions
USCIS identifies Form I-290B as the notice used for an AAO appeal or a motion within its scope. A different tribunal or proceeding can require a different form. The person entitled to file, the place to file, fee, edition, and timing must be checked for the actual case.
This guide does not freeze a fee, postal address, or filing deadline from a historical decision. The official Form I-290B page contains current alerts and links to the form instructions. It reported a filing-location change when checked on October 17, 2026.
Reopening and reconsideration ask different questions
Under 8 CFR 103.5(a)(2), reopening requires new facts supported by affidavits or other documentary evidence. Under 8 CFR 103.5(a)(3), reconsideration addresses an incorrect application of law or USCIS policy and must establish error based on the record at the time of the decision.
A submission of new evidence does not, by itself, explain why a motion to reconsider meets its separate standard. The regulation also addresses timing, jurisdiction, and other filing requirements; the distinction here is a reading guide, not a complete motion checklist.
Keep procedure and substantive findings separate
When reading an older decision, identify which filing the AAO accepted, rejected, dismissed, or remanded, and what findings it actually reached. A remand calls for further proceedings. Granting a motion does not necessarily approve the underlying petition.
For a source-backed historical example, read the evidence framework alongside the library’s appeal-rejection explanation.
Primary sources
USCIS Form I-290B: current form, instructions, and filing alerts.
8 CFR 103.5: motions to reopen and reconsider. These sources were checked on October 17, 2026.