AAO evidence pattern

EB-1A Appeal Rejections: Filing Requirements and the Underlying Petition

EB-1A Appeal Rejections: Filing Requirements and the Underlying Petition

Read this corrected evidence-pattern guide for Apr202012_04B2203, with the original disposition, source passages, and USCIS PDF.

An appeal filing is different from an initial petition

A rejection of an appeal for a filing defect does not establish that the initial EB-1A petition contained no evidence or claimed no criteria. The previous version incorrectly referred to the National Interest Waiver and asserted a universal 15-day deadline for EB-1A petitions. Those statements were wrong and have been removed.

What the source decision shows

Apr202012_04B2203 concerns an appeal after denial of an underlying Form I-140 petition. Pages 2 to 3 explain that an incomplete appeal filing was not accepted and that the corrected filing was received too late. The AAO rejected the appeal. Its discussion concerns the appeal filing, not a general filing deadline for all initial EB-1A petitions.

Keep the procedural questions separate

Identify the decision being challenged, the filing involved, and the particular defect described. An appeal, motion to reopen, and motion to reconsider have different functions and requirements. A claim about new facts for reopening does not describe every requirement for reconsideration.

A procedural disposition also differs from a merits determination about an evidentiary criterion or the total record. Do not convert an absent criterion discussion in a short procedural decision into a finding that no criteria were claimed or satisfied.

Current filing instructions

This is a historical example. Consult the current USCIS Form I-290B instructions for present filing requirements instead of carrying a deadline or fee from an older decision into a current filing.

Primary source

Original USCIS AAO decision Apr202012_04B2203 (PDF)

Sources, editorial method, and corrections