AAO research
An elementary teacher met judging and scholarly authorship, but not contributions or high salary. Read the AAO's April 16, 2025 reasoning and source pages.
Decision snapshot
Decision detail | Source-backed value |
|---|---|
Decision ID | APR162025_03B2203 |
Disposition stated in the source | Appeal dismissed. Judging and scholarly authorship were accepted; two criteria were insufficient in this record, and final merits was reserved. |
Source location | Final order, page 6; Disposition context, page 2; Disposition context, page 5 |
What changed on appeal
SCOPS initially accepted judging. On appeal, the AAO also accepted the elementary school teacher's co-authorship of a scholarly article in a professional publication. The result was two accepted categories, not a petition that submitted evidence for only two. The decision describes the alternative of a major internationally recognized award and, without that achievement, at least three of ten regulatory categories. This petitioner did not claim the major-award alternative.
Source: page 1, page 2, page 4, page 5.
Why the contribution evidence fell short
The teacher described STEM curriculum development, mentoring new teachers, and reviewing state curricula. Supporters praised improvements in students' skills, the school environment, and support for educators. The AAO found that the letters and record did not explain major significance in the broader field. The decision distinguished the merit of teaching from proof that this particular teacher's contributions met the EB-1A contribution category.
One scholarly article satisfied the authorship category
The record included an abstract of an August 2023 distance-learning article listing the teacher as a co-author. Information about its peer-reviewed journal identified an audience of teachers and other education professionals. The AAO withdrew SCOPS' contrary finding and accepted authorship. Its discussion expressly recognized that a single qualifying piece of evidence can suffice in a particular evidentiary category.
The salary comparison was specific to this record
A 2023 W-2 showed earnings of $79,166. One submitted wage comparison listed $69,730 as the highest level, but another submitted O*NET comparison showed local elementary teachers in the top ten percent earning at least $84,010. The AAO found that the combined record did not establish comparatively high pay. It also rejected comparing this U.S. salary with Philippine wages because the teacher worked in the United States. These figures explain this finding; the decision does not establish a universal salary amount or a rule that every EB-1A occupation must use one fixed percentile cutoff.
Source: page 5.
Which questions the AAO did not decide
The teacher did not challenge SCOPS' findings concerning lesser awards, qualifying association membership, and a leading or critical role. The AAO treated those issues as waived on appeal. After accepting only judging and authorship, it reserved final merits and dismissed the appeal. This was not a new final-merits rejection, and it does not support the earlier summary's assertion that a major internationally recognized award can never serve as an alternative to the three-category route.
Source: page 2, page 3, page 5, page 6.
Read this historical decision in context
This is a non-precedent AAO decision about a particular record. Its historical reasoning is distinct from current guidance. For the present framework, read the initial evidence guide, the final merits guide, and the USCIS Policy Manual.