AAO research
Read this corrected case study for Dec042009_02B2203, with the original disposition, source passages, and USCIS PDF.
Source-based correction
This revised explanation replaces unsupported statements in the earlier summary. The original decision controls the account of the proceeding, evidence, and outcome. Its wording below is attributed to the source; it is not a general rule for every EB-1A petition.
Disposition in the original decision
The appeal is dismissed.
Read the final order on page 11.
Relevant source passages
The employment-based immigrant visa petition was denied by the Director, Texas Service Center. The petition is now before the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) on appeal. The appeal will be dismissed. The petitioner seeks classification as an employment-based immigrant pursuant to section 203(b)(l)(A) of the Immigration and Nationality Act (the Act), 8 U.S.C. 5 1153(b)(l)(A), as an alien of extraordinary ability in the arts and athletics. The director determined the petitioner had not established the sustained national or international acclaim necessary to qualify for classification as an alien of extraordinary ability. More specifically, the director found that the petitioner had failed to demonstrate receipt of a major, internationally recognized award, or that he meets at least three of the regulatory criteria at 8 C.F.R. 5 204.5(h)(3). On appeal, counsel for the petitioner argues that the petitioner meets the statutory requirements and […]
USCIS AAO decision Dec042009_02B2203, page 2. This is a passage from the document; read the full page for context.
DISCUSSION: The employment-based immigrant visa petition was denied by the Director, Texas Service Center. The petition is now before the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) on appeal. The appeal will be dismissed. The petitioner seeks classification as an employment-based immigrant pursuant to section 203(b)(l)(A) of the Immigration and Nationality Act (the Act), 8 U.S.C. 5 1153(b)(l)(A), as an alien of extraordinary ability in the arts and athletics. The director determined the petitioner had not established the sustained national or international acclaim necessary to qualify for classification as an alien of extraordinary ability. More specifically, the director found that the petitioner had failed to demonstrate receipt of a major, internationally recognized award, or that he meets at least three of the regulatory criteria at 8 C.F.R. 5 204.5(h)(3). On appeal, counsel for the petitioner argues that the petitioner meets the statutory requirements and at least three of the regulatory criteria at 8 C.F.R. 5 204.5(h)(3). Section 203(b) of the Act states, in pertinent part, that: (1) Priority Workers. - Visas shall first be made available . . . to qualified immigrants who are aliens described in any of the following subparagraphs (A) […]
USCIS AAO decision Dec042009_02B2203, page 2. This is a passage from the document; read the full page for context.
however, that the petitioner must show that he has sustained national or international acclaim at the very top level. This petition, filed on February 23, 2007 seeks to classify the petitioner as an alien with extraordinary ability as a bodybuilder. The regulation at 8 C.F.R. 5 204.5(h)(3) indicates that an alien can establish sustained national or international acclaim through evidence of a one-time achievement (that is, a major, internationally recognized award). Barring the alien's receipt of such an award, the regulation outlines ten criteria, at least three of which must be satisfied for an alien to establish the sustained acclaim necessary to qualify as an alien of extraordinary ability. Counsel alleges on appeal: It seems to us that the Service wants MORE than just satisfaction of the criteria established by the Regulations, i.e. at lest three out of ten characteristics, listed in Section 204.5(h)(3)(i-x). We refer the AAO to its Decision in the case WAC 03 118 54147, page 3: The Language [of the Regulations] does not support the director's assertion that meeting three criteria is insufficient evidence of extraordinary ability. . . Once there criteria are met under this […]
USCIS AAO decision Dec042009_02B2203, page 3. This is a passage from the document; read the full page for context.
How to read this record
Distinguish the director’s findings, the petitioner’s arguments, and the AAO’s conclusions. Identify the criteria actually discussed, rather than assuming that the number discussed is the total number in the regulation. For the initial evidentiary route, qualifying documentation under at least three of ten categories is required when a qualifying one-time achievement is not established. A remand, a grant of a motion, and approval of the underlying petition are different outcomes.
Read historical reasoning in the context of its date and the complete record. This non-precedent decision is an example, not binding precedent or a prediction of another case.