AAO research
Read the corrected case study for Aug252009_05B2203, with the original disposition, attributed source passages, and links to the USCIS decision.
Corrected source reading
The earlier article overstated the legal requirements or the implications of this record. This replacement separates the document’s findings from a general rule. Read the attributed passages and the complete decision before drawing a lesson for another case.
Disposition in the source
The appeal is dismissed.
Passages from the original record
The employment-based immigrant visa petition was denied by the Director, Nebraska Service Center. The petition is now before the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) on appeal. The appeal will be dismissed. The petitioner seeks classification as an employment-based immigrant pursuant to section 5 203(b)(l)(A) of the Immigration and Nationality Act (the Act), 8 U.S.C. 1153(b)(l)(A), as an alien of extraordinary ability in athletics. The director determined the petitioner had not established the sustained national or international acclaim necessary to qualify for classification as an alien of extraordinary ability. More specifically, the director found that the petitioner had failed to demonstrate receipt of a major, internationally recognized award, or that he meets at least three of the regulatory criteria at 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(h)(3). On appeal, counsel for the petitioner argues that the petitioner meets the statutory requirements and 5 at least three of the regulatory criteria at 8 C.F.R. 204.5(h)(3). Section 203(b) of the Act states, in pertinent part, that: (1) […]
Original USCIS decision Aug252009_05B2203, page 2. Ellipses mark an excerpt; read the full page for the surrounding discussion.
DISCUSSION: The employment-based immigrant visa petition was denied by the Director, Nebraska Service Center. The petition is now before the Administrative Appeals Office (AAO) on appeal. The appeal will be dismissed. The petitioner seeks classification as an employment-based immigrant pursuant to section 5 203(b)(l)(A) of the Immigration and Nationality Act (the Act), 8 U.S.C. 1153(b)(l)(A), as an alien of extraordinary ability in athletics. The director determined the petitioner had not established the sustained national or international acclaim necessary to qualify for classification as an alien of extraordinary ability. More specifically, the director found that the petitioner had failed to demonstrate receipt of a major, internationally recognized award, or that he meets at least three of the regulatory criteria at 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(h)(3). On appeal, counsel for the petitioner argues that the petitioner meets the statutory requirements and 5 at least three of the regulatory criteria at 8 C.F.R. 204.5(h)(3). Section 203(b) of the Act states, in pertinent part, that: (1) Priority Workers. - Visas shall first be made available . . . to qualified immigrants who are aliens described […]
Original USCIS decision Aug252009_05B2203, page 2. Ellipses mark an excerpt; read the full page for the surrounding discussion.
however, that the petitioner must show that he has sustained national or international acclaim at the very top level. This petition, filed on February 21, 2007, seeks to classify the petitioner as an alien with 5 extraordinary ability as a karate-do trainer. The regulation at 8 C.F.R. 204.5(h) requires the beneficiary to "continue work in the area of expertise." The petitioner intends to work as a trainer in the United States. While a karate practitioner and a karate trainer or coach certainly share knowledge of karate, the two rely on very different sets of basic skills. Thus, competitive karate and training are not the same area of expertise. This interpretation has been upheld in Federal Court. In Lee v. I.N.S., 237 F. Supp. 2d 914 (N.D. Ill. 2002), the court stated: It is reasonable to interpret continuing to work in one's "area of extraordinary ability" as working in the same profession in which one has extraordinary ability, not necessarily in any profession in that field. For example, Lee's extraordinary ability as a baseball player does not imply that he also […]
Original USCIS decision Aug252009_05B2203, page 3. Ellipses mark an excerpt; read the full page for the surrounding discussion.
Questions for reading this decision
Identify which statements describe the petitioner’s position, the director’s reasoning, and the AAO’s conclusions. The number of claims discussed in a particular case is not the number of regulatory categories. A case’s outcome does not make every listed category a requirement in every petition.
For the current framework, read the initial evidence guide and the relevant criterion guide. Distinguish the initial categories from final merits. Historical non-precedent reasoning must be read in context; a motion, remand, or dismissed appeal does not by itself establish every underlying factual proposition.