AAO research

AAO EB-1A Decision AUG242018_01B2203: Evidence and Source Findings

AAO EB-1A Decision AUG242018_01B2203: Evidence and Source Findings

Read this corrected case study for AUG242018_01B2203, with the original disposition, source passages, and USCIS PDF.

Source-based correction

This revised explanation replaces unsupported statements in the earlier summary. The original decision controls the account of the proceeding, evidence, and outcome. Its wording below is attributed to the source; it is not a general rule for every EB-1A petition.

Disposition in the original decision

The appeal is dismissed.

Read the final order on page 8.

Relevant source passages

Matter of L-S- The term "extraordinary ability" refers only to those individuals in "that small percentage who have risen to the very top of the field of endeavor." 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(h)(2). The implementing regulation at 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(h)(3) sets forth a multi-part analysis. First, a petitioner can demonstrate sustained acclaim and the recognition of his or her achievements in the field through a one-time achievement (that is, a major, internationally recognized award). If that petitioner does not submit this evidence, then he or she must provide sufficient qualifying documentation that meets at least three of the ten categories listed at 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(h)(3)(i)- (x) (including items such as awards, published material in certain media, and scholarly articles). - Satisfaction of at least three criteria, however, does not, in and of itself, establish eligibility for this classification. See […]

USCIS AAO decision AUG242018_01B2203, page 2. This is a passage from the document; read the full page for context.

evidence, to deteni-line whether the fact to be proven is probably true"). Accordingly, where a petitioner submits qualifying evidence under at least three criteria, we will determine whether the totality of the record shows sustained national or international acclaim and demonstrates that the individual is among the small percentage at the very top of the field of endeavor. II. ANALYSIS The Director found that the Petitioner meets three of the evidentiary criteria at 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(h)(3)(i)(x), those relating to service as a judge of.the work of others, published materials about her, and authorship of scholarly articles. But he discounted the documentary evidence relating to the Petitioner's career as a gymnast in his analysis of both the evidentiary criteria and the final merits determination. We disagree with the Director's analysis on this issue, and will instead evaluate all evidence relating to the Petitioner's gymnastics achievements as both an athlete and a coach. 1 1 We note that the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services Adjudicator's Field Manual (AFM) provides: In general, if a beneficiary has clearly achieved recent national or international acclaim as an athlete and has sustained that acclaim in […]

USCIS AAO decision AUG242018_01B2203, page 2. This is a passage from the document; read the full page for context.

_On appeal, the Petitioner asserts that in addition to the criteria which the Direqor determined she met, she also meets the criterion for original athletic contributions of major significance, and that the record establishes her sustained national and international acclaim in her field. We have reviewed all of the evidence in the record of proceedings, and while the Petitioner has submitted the required initial evidence for at least three evidentiary criteria, it does not support a finding that the Petitioner has sustained national or international acclaim in gymnastics, or is one of the small percentage at the top of her field. A. Evidentiary Criteria Documentation of the individual's receipt of lesser nationally or internationally recognized prizes or awards for excellence in the .field of endeavor. 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(h)(3)(i) The Director acknowledged the evidence of the Petitioner's awards received at national and international tournaments, but declined to consider these since the Petitioner is petitioning as a gymnastics coach. The record includes certificates and other evidence which establish that, as a gymnast, she participated in prestigious international gymnastics tournaments, including the 1991 and 1992 contributing towards the Chinese women's team's fourth-place […]

USCIS AAO decision AUG242018_01B2203, page 3. This is a passage from the document; read the full page for context.

How to read this record

Distinguish the director’s findings, the petitioner’s arguments, and the AAO’s conclusions. Identify the criteria actually discussed, rather than assuming that the number discussed is the total number in the regulation. For the initial evidentiary route, qualifying documentation under at least three of ten categories is required when a qualifying one-time achievement is not established. A remand, a grant of a motion, and approval of the underlying petition are different outcomes.

Read historical reasoning in the context of its date and the complete record. This non-precedent decision is an example, not binding precedent or a prediction of another case.

Primary source

Original USCIS AAO decision AUG242018_01B2203 (PDF)

Sources, editorial method, and corrections