AAO research
Read the source-backed explanation of AUG102020_02B2203, the AAO's actual findings, and corrections to the previous article.
Outcome and accepted criteria
In AUG102020_02B2203, the AAO sustained a musician and producer's appeal. Pages 2 to 3 accept published material, judging, and display at artistic exhibitions or showcases. Pages 3 to 6 evaluate the overall evidence, and page 6 concludes that eligibility was established.
What the AAO corrected
The director had not adequately considered the article evidence. Page 3 identifies coverage in major newspapers and industry publications. It also explains that the judging criterion did not require the judging activity itself to demonstrate sustained acclaim at the initial criterion stage.
The AAO disagreed with the director's view that artistic display was limited to visual artists and accepted evidence of the petitioner's own performances at music festivals. This is the reasoning of this non-precedent 2020 decision; consult current USCIS guidance when evaluating a present record.
Correction
The previous article incorrectly described published material as potentially fabricated, identified leading or critical role as one of the three accepted criteria, and referred to five required EB-1A criteria. Those statements have been removed.
Primary sources
Non-precedent decisions explain the records before the AAO. They are not binding precedent or predictions of another case.