AAO research
Read the source-backed explanation of APR042018_01B2203, the AAO's actual findings, and corrections to the previous article.
The appeal was sustained
APR042018_01B2203 concerns a research scientist. The director had accepted judging, original contributions of major significance, and scholarly article authorship but denied the petition at final merits. The AAO agreed with the three criterion findings and sustained the appeal.
How the record supported final merits
Pages 3 to 4 discuss completed manuscript reviews, highly cited publications in context, citing works that discussed the research at length, and detailed expert explanations. Page 4 also describes patent documents, commercialization evidence, and independent users of the petitioner's work.
Correction to the previous explanation
This was not a denial for weak commercial success evidence. The performing arts commercial success criterion was not the basis of this chemistry research decision, and the source does not support the prior article's allegation that commercialization evidence was potentially fabricated. Commercialization was part of the evidence supporting research impact and the favorable totality assessment.
Primary sources
Non-precedent decisions explain the records before the AAO. They are not binding precedent or predictions of another case.