AAO research
The historical dismissal found professional exams, general business letters, incomplete salary translations, and unsupported comparisons insufficient.
The case concerned an investment manager’s older business record
The petitioner sought extraordinary-ability classification as an investment manager. The AAO reviewed membership, original contributions, leading or critical role, and compensation evidence and found no criterion established. It also noted that the significant finance-related evidence predated filing by years, while more recent listed employment involved education. The source does not announce a fixed unemployment limit or a universal expiration date for business achievements.
Source: Dec032009_08B2203 page 2; Dec032009_08B2203 page 3; Dec032009_08B2203 page 7; Dec032009_08B2203 page 8.
Professional qualifications and business praise did not establish the claimed categories
Certificates reflected qualifying examinations and training, without sufficient evidence of association admission requiring outstanding achievements judged by recognized experts. Business letters described client development, contracts, and expertise but did not adequately document contributions of major significance. Counsel’s claim that an investment study prompted a multimillion-dollar investment lacked supporting documentation. The article reports that as an unproved claim, not an independently verified business result.
Source: Dec032009_08B2203 page 3; Dec032009_08B2203 page 4; Dec032009_08B2203 page 5.
Role and salary evidence left separate documentation gaps
The record did not sufficiently explain duties, accomplishments, or qualifying organizational impact for the role claim. Compensation material had an incomplete translation, and the asserted sevenfold wage comparison lacked corroborating evidence of the pay and relevant benchmarks. The AAO dismissed on those stated grounds. Its historical discussion does not impose a mandatory organizational chart, require sole responsibility for company success, or automatically exclude letters from colleagues.
Source: Dec032009_08B2203 page 5; Dec032009_08B2203 page 6; Dec032009_08B2203 page 7; Dec032009_08B2203 page 8.
Current framework and related reading
The decisions above are non-precedent assessments of particular records. Historical reasoning is identified as historical; consult current guidance for the present framework.