AAO research

AAO AUG252014_01B2203: What Letters Proved

AAO AUG252014_01B2203: What Letters Proved

The AAO credited letters as evidence of a leading or critical role, but found the record insufficient for several other EB-1A criteria.

The AAO did not reject letters across the board

The decision draws distinctions by criterion. It found documentary evidence, including letters, sufficient to establish the petitioner’s judging and leading-or-critical role in producing and arranging award-winning songs in Armenia. The decision therefore contradicts the draft’s broad claim that letters and testimonials cannot replace primary documents for any EB-1A criterion. It instead evaluated whether each item of evidence proved the regulatory element at issue.

Source: AUG252014_01B2203 page 7; AUG252014_01B2203 page 8.

Award claims failed because the record did not show the petitioner personally received the awards

The initial record contained award photographs and certificates that did not name the petitioner. Letters said he contributed to award-winning songs or that producers and arrangers were recipients, but the AAO found no supporting evidence that he was a named recipient of any award. It explained that secondary evidence may be used only after showing primary evidence does not exist or cannot be obtained, and affidavits only after secondary evidence is unavailable. The source does not say every award claim requires only a certificate; it describes the evidence hierarchy and the missing proof in this record.

Source: AUG252014_01B2203 page 5; AUG252014_01B2203 page 6.

The AAO credited the role evidence but rejected the separate artistic-display claim

The AAO found sufficient documentary evidence, including letters, that the petitioner played a leading or critical role in producing and arranging award-winning songs in Armenia. By contrast, it found that singers’ performances of songs the petitioner produced or arranged did not establish display of his work under the artistic-exhibition criterion. A page summary that treats “artistic display” as one of the accepted criteria reverses the source’s conclusion.

Source: AUG252014_01B2203 page 8.

Salary required evidence about his own earnings and a relevant comparison

The petitioner relied on colleagues’ assertions that he was highly paid and an article calling him an expensive specialist. The AAO found no documentary support for the claims, questioned the publication and article authorship, and explained that salary evidence should include the petitioner’s own remuneration and earnings comparisons for people doing similar work at the top level. It identified primary income evidence such as bank statements or tax records and said the petitioner had not shown relevant primary or secondary evidence was unavailable.

Source: AUG252014_01B2203 page 8; AUG252014_01B2203 page 9; AUG252014_01B2203 page 10.

Commercial-success claims needed receipts or sales evidence and a link to the petitioner’s success

Letters from recording artists and a distributor asserted commercial success, but the record lacked box-office receipts or sales documentation. Although it showed the petitioner worked on songs, concerts, and albums, the AAO found no independent evidence that the albums were commercial successes or that the petitioner was responsible for that success. The decision applies the regulation’s stated sales/receipts focus to that record.

Source: AUG252014_01B2203 page 10.

The appeal failed at the three-criterion threshold

The AAO found that the petitioner did not establish at least three criteria. It stated that it therefore did not need to explain a final-merits conclusion, and dismissed the appeal. This decision is a nonprecedent example; it does not establish that letters are categorically inadequate or that the same document type will fail every criterion.

Source: AUG252014_01B2203 page 2; AUG252014_01B2203 page 3; AUG252014_01B2203 page 11.

Current framework and related reading

The decisions above are non-precedent assessments of particular records. Historical reasoning is identified as historical; consult current guidance for the present framework.

Primary sources reviewed for this article

Sources and corrections methodology