AAO research

AAO Dec142010_01B2203: Political Scientist and Educator Evidence Review

AAO Dec142010_01B2203: Political Scientist and Educator Evidence Review

The AAO rejected the political scientist’s grant, publication, role, and salary evidence, found sustained acclaim and continued U.S. work unproven, and dismissed the appeal.

The source concerns a Georgian political scientist, historian, and educator

The petitioner filed as a researcher historian, political scientist, and educator. The AAO examined a course-development grant, APSA membership and participation, one monograph review, conference papers, monographs, academic employment, and salary evidence. This single case does not support claims about routine AAO outcomes across disciplines.

Source: Dec142010_01B2203 page 2; Dec142010_01B2203 page 5; Dec142010_01B2203 page 19.

The course-development grants funded future courses and did not establish qualifying awards

The Central European University Curriculum Resource Center grants funded proposed courses, including stipends, teaching materials, travel, and workshops. The AAO found the program evaluated proposals for innovation, curriculum reform, regional relevance, quality, and feasibility, but did not find that this established the petitioner’s receipt of nationally or internationally recognized prizes for excellence in political science, history, or education. A separate 1999 grant lacked evidence of its significance. The holding is specific to these educational grants and this record; it does not declare that every grant can never qualify as an award.

Source: Dec142010_01B2203 page 5; Dec142010_01B2203 page 6; Dec142010_01B2203 page 7.

APSA membership did not show selection for outstanding achievement

The record showed the petitioner was a Developing World Member of APSA and participated in a conference, but did not include bylaws or official admission rules showing outstanding achievement judged by recognized experts was required. Conference participation did not prove selective membership. The decision does not state that APSA membership can never qualify; it found the submitted membership evidence insufficient.

Source: Dec142010_01B2203 page 8.

Published-material evidence lacked required details and proof of major-media status

One article lacked its date and publication name; another discussed the petitioner’s political analysis but was not about her and lacked an author; the record did not establish that the relevant outlets were professional or major media. Keep the published-material criterion distinct from scholarly authorship: the decision does not require volume, issue, page-range, or DOI fields as universal metadata elements.

Source: Dec142010_01B2203 page 9.

The AAO found one monograph review and teaching evaluations insufficient as judging

The evidence documented review of a single monograph in 1999, but the AAO read the criterion’s reference to judging the work of “others” as requiring more than that one review. Membership on an academic council and a USAID monitoring certificate did not establish participation as a judge of others’ work. The AAO also considered, in final merits, whether peer review was extensive enough to distinguish the petitioner; it said a substantial number of independent journal review requests or editorial service could be relevant. The source does not set a universal numerical quota.

Source: Dec142010_01B2203 page 9; Dec142010_01B2203 page 10; Dec142010_01B2203 page 17; Dec142010_01B2203 page 18.

Letters did not establish original contributions of major significance

The AAO recognized descriptions of conference papers, teaching, and curriculum development but found no objective evidence showing that the conference papers influenced political science beyond the sessions where they were presented. It also found the letters did not identify specific original contributions or show their influence on independent scholars or the field as a whole. General praise and workplace contributions were not enough on this record. The source does not make citations, awards, or invitations the sole permitted proof.

Source: Dec142010_01B2203 page 10; Dec142010_01B2203 page 11; Dec142010_01B2203 page 12; Dec142010_01B2203 page 13; Dec142010_01B2203 page 14; Dec142010_01B2203 page 15.

Monographs and conference presentations did not meet scholarly-authorship or artistic-display criteria

The petitioner submitted two monographs with incomplete, uncertified translations and no proof the works appeared in professional or major trade publications or other major media. Conference presentations and workshops did not convert the material into qualifying scholarly articles. The AAO also found that the artistic-display criterion did not apply to a historian or political scientist based on conference presentations and workshops.

Source: Dec142010_01B2203 page 15; Dec142010_01B2203 page 16; Dec142010_01B2203 page 18.

Titles and internships did not establish leading or critical roles for distinguished organizations

The record did not show the organizations had distinguished reputations, how the petitioner’s duties fit into their hierarchies, or how her role contributed to organizational success. The AAO considered a university position, internships, and other affiliations but found the evidence insufficient for the criterion.

Source: Dec142010_01B2203 page 16.

The salary comparison used the wrong comparator

The petitioner documented a monthly salary of 600 GEL and asserted that the national average was 120–150 GEL, but supplied no data supporting that assertion. The AAO also found national average pay for Georgian workers generally was not the right comparison; the criterion called for evidence relative to others in the petitioner’s field, and no objective salary data for history or political-science professors was provided.

Source: Dec142010_01B2203 page 17.

The decision also found continued U.S. work was not documented

Beyond the extraordinary-ability criteria, the AAO found no prospective-employer letter, prearranged commitment, or petitioner statement explaining plans to continue work in her area of expertise in the United States. It found that requirement unproven and dismissed the appeal.

Source: Dec142010_01B2203 page 18; Dec142010_01B2203 page 19.

The AAO conducted final merits and rejected the claims in the aggregate

The AAO found the course awards and memberships did not show sustained acclaim, the single review and conference activity did not establish top-of-field recognition, and the remaining record did not distinguish the petitioner in the aggregate. It concluded the petitioner had not shown a one-time major award or three qualifying criteria.

Source: Dec142010_01B2203 page 17; Dec142010_01B2203 page 18; Dec142010_01B2203 page 19.

Current framework and related reading

The decisions above are non-precedent assessments of particular records. Historical reasoning is identified as historical; consult current guidance for the present framework.

Primary sources reviewed for this article

Sources and corrections methodology