AAO evidence pattern
Distinguish procedural motion requirements, evidentiary insufficiency, and misrepresentation findings using original USCIS AAO decisions.
A procedural defect is different from insufficient evidence
A petition can fail because its evidence does not establish eligibility. A motion can also fail to satisfy its own filing requirements. These are different questions. The previous version incorrectly treated empty extraction fields as proof that petitions had presented no criteria and asserted an unsupported frequency claim.
A source example
In APR182013_01B2203, page 2 identifies a missing statement about judicial proceedings. Pages 2 to 5 also explain why the motions did not establish a supported basis to reopen or reconsider the AAO's prior decision.
Dec152011_01B2203 likewise distinguishes a motion's requirements from the underlying evidence. Pages 5 to 7 discuss a separate willful material misrepresentation finding, while pages 7 to 10 address the motion and evidentiary record. A fraud finding is not simply a synonym for a procedural defect.
How to read the outcome
Record whether the document concerns an initial petition, appeal, motion to reopen, or motion to reconsider. Identify the actual grounds discussed and the final order. Do not infer missing evidence from an empty summary field or infer approval from a remand.
Primary sources
Non-precedent decisions explain the records before the AAO. They are not binding precedent or predictions of another case.