AAO research

Taekwondo Coach: Student Results Met Contributions, Not Awards

Taekwondo Coach: Student Results Met Contributions, Not Awards

Coached athletes’ results met original contributions, but the AAO rejected other claims and dismissed the appeal for failure to meet three criteria.

Decision snapshot

Decision detail

Source-backed value

Decision ID

Dec022011_02B2203

Disposition stated in the source

The appeal is dismissed.

Source location

Final order, page 26

The requested U.S. work was coaching, so the AAO assessed acclaim in coaching

The petitioner sought to work in the United States as a Taekwondo Headmaster and Coach. The AAO treated competitive athletics and coaching as different areas of expertise in this case because the petitioner’s competitive career ended in 1999 and he did not show an intent to compete in the United States. The petition therefore had to establish extraordinary ability through coaching evidence. This discussion is case-specific and nonprecedential.

Source: Dec022011_02B2203 page 5; Dec022011_02B2203 page 6.

The petitioner’s old competition medals did not show awards for coaching

The AAO did not count the petitioner’s 1990s taekwondo competition awards toward recognition as a coach. It found the 2009 World Taekwondo Federation citation and Presidential Physical Fitness Award were not documented as nationally or internationally recognized awards for excellence in coaching. Student awards were not the petitioner’s own awards under this criterion; student results were considered separately under contributions.

Source: Dec022011_02B2203 page 6; Dec022011_02B2203 page 7; Dec022011_02B2203 page 8.

The membership record did not establish qualifying associations

A USA Taekwondo card did not document outstanding-achievement admission standards. The AAO also found that Kukkiwon Dan testing and rank requirements were not tantamount to outstanding achievements or proof that a Dan rank was required for association membership. It interpreted the criterion’s plural “associations” to require more than one association. That is the AAO’s reasoning in this nonprecedential 2011 decision, not a universal rule stated here as current controlling law.

Source: Dec022011_02B2203 page 8; Dec022011_02B2203 page 9; Dec022011_02B2203 page 10; Dec022011_02B2203 page 11; Dec022011_02B2203 page 12.

The articles did not meet the published-material criterion for a coach

The AAO identified multiple defects in press evidence: some pieces were about teams or tournaments, not the petitioner; brief mentions did not make them primarily about him; required dates or authors were missing; translation certifications did not adequately identify translated items; and evidence of major-media distribution was lacking. The articles concerned competitive achievements, not coaching, the field in which he planned to continue in the United States.

Source: Dec022011_02B2203 page 12; Dec022011_02B2203 page 13; Dec022011_02B2203 page 14.

Referee service was not shown to be judging competitors’ work

Certificates described the petitioner as a referee, but did not establish that he acted as a judge. A Korea Taekwondo Association letter and World Taekwondo Federation rules distinguished referees, who control matches and enforce procedure, from judges, who award points. The AAO found no evidence that the petitioner judged competitors or details identifying the categories he refereed and athletes involved.

Source: Dec022011_02B2203 page 14; Dec022011_02B2203 page 15; Dec022011_02B2203 page 16; Dec022011_02B2203 page 17.

National results by coached athletes established original contributions

The AAO found the original-contributions criterion met. Evidence showed athletes coached by the petitioner won medals in Korean national competitions in 2002–2003 and one student won gold in the Black belt division at the 2007 U.S. Open. It distinguished these student results from the petitioner’s own awards: the results supported the coach’s contributions.

Source: Dec022011_02B2203 page 18; Dec022011_02B2203 page 19.

Head-coach work was documented, but the team’s distinguished reputation was not

The record supported that the petitioner served as head coach for Yeong Cheon City Hall Taekwondo Team, but the AAO found the evidence did not establish the team’s distinguished reputation during his tenure. Letters made assertions without independent comparative results; Google search snippets did not provide full articles or establish reputation during 2002–2003. The AAO also interpreted the criterion’s plural wording to require roles at more than one distinguished organization. This is the decision’s case-specific, nonprecedential reasoning.

Source: Dec022011_02B2203 page 19; Dec022011_02B2203 page 20.

One criterion met was not enough; the appeal was dismissed

The AAO found original contributions satisfied but concluded that the petitioner had not established a major internationally recognized award or at least three of the ten criteria. At final merits, it found the record did not show sustained national or international acclaim at the very top of coaching. The petition was denied and the appeal dismissed. This is a nonprecedential decision and a fact-specific example, not binding authority.

Source: Dec022011_02B2203 page 19; Dec022011_02B2203 page 20; Dec022011_02B2203 page 22; Dec022011_02B2203 page 25; Dec022011_02B2203 page 26.

Current framework and related reading

The decisions above are non-precedent assessments of particular records. Historical reasoning is identified as historical; consult current guidance for the present framework.

Primary sources reviewed for this article

Sources and corrections methodology