AAO research
The AAO withdrew the director’s favorable leading-role and high-salary findings and found no criteria met.
Decision snapshot
Decision detail | Source-backed value |
|---|---|
Decision ID | AUG272019_02B2203 |
Disposition stated in the source | The AAO dismissed an EB-1A petition for a record-label creative director. It found no qualifying criteria. Awards did not establish nationally or internationally recognized prizes; membership rules were not documented; media lacked complete/authored items or was not about the beneficiary; judging letters lacked details; project work and praise did not show original contributions of major significance; leading-role letters did not establish role importance or distinguished organizational reputation; and salary evidence lacked a proper comparison to high salaries in the relevant metropolitan field. The AAO withdrew the director’s prior favorable findings on leading role and salary. Because the initial-evidence threshold of three criteria was not met, it said a Kazarian final-merits determination was unnecessary, though it also stated the aggregate record did not support acclaim. Appeal dismissed. |
Awards and competition results did not establish recognized prizes for excellence
The beneficiary and coworkers shared several Clio awards, competition finalist placements, and other advertising/design prizes. The record did not show the specific Clio awards or other prizes were nationally or internationally recognized for excellence. The AAO distinguished Grand Clio recognition from ordinary gold/silver/bronze awards and noted finalist status did not itself establish a recognized prize.
Source: AUG272019_02B2203 page 2; AUG272019_02B2203 page 3; AUG272019_02B2203 page 4.
Membership evidence did not show selective admission based on outstanding achievement
Letters and website screenshots identified membership in XH Collective and One Club for Art and Copy, but did not establish the membership requirements or that recognized experts judged members to have outstanding achievements.
Source: AUG272019_02B2203 page 4.
Published-material evidence was incomplete or not about the beneficiary
Screenshots from websites lacked full articles, author identification, and evidence of readership establishing major-media status. Other coverage discussed client projects rather than the beneficiary; even some major-media items were not about him.
Source: AUG272019_02B2203 page 4; AUG272019_02B2203 page 5.
Letters did not establish that the beneficiary judged work in his field
Letters said the beneficiary lectured and judged exhibitions or an award, but did not identify whose work or which projects he evaluated. The record also lacked sufficient information about the school, its academic programs, or the award’s focus to connect the activity to judging work in the field.
Source: AUG272019_02B2203 page 5.
Campaigns and praise did not prove original contributions of major significance
Awards, media attention to campaigns, and letters did not show the beneficiary’s specific work had significantly influenced the creative-direction field. Articles often did not mention him or only listed him among many contributors. The data-for-groceries pop-up had media attention but no evidence of expansion or meaningful field-wide impact; other projects lacked detailed corroboration.
Source: AUG272019_02B2203 page 6; AUG272019_02B2203 page 7.
The record did not establish a leading or critical role for distinguished organizations
The AAO withdrew the director’s favorable finding. Letters confirmed employment and project activity but did not explain how the beneficiary’s role was leading within the organizations or critical to their overall outcomes. Self-promotional company materials did not establish distinguished reputations.
Source: AUG272019_02B2203 page 8; AUG272019_02B2203 page 9.
Salary evidence did not establish high remuneration relative to the relevant field
A $150,000 salary and a Salary.com median for creative directors did not establish significantly high remuneration. The comparison did not identify a geographic region and did not compare the beneficiary with high salaries for creative directors in the relevant metropolitan area. The AAO withdrew the director’s favorable finding.
Source: AUG272019_02B2203 page 9; AUG272019_02B2203 page 10.
Fewer than three criteria were met; no formal final merits determination was required
The AAO concluded the petition lacked evidence meeting at least three criteria. It expressly said a final-merits determination was not required, while advising that its aggregate review also did not support acclaim. It dismissed the appeal and treated each stated reason as an independent and alternate basis.
Source: AUG272019_02B2203 page 10; AUG272019_02B2203 page 11.
Current framework and related reading
The decisions above are non-precedent assessments of particular records. Historical reasoning is identified as historical; consult current guidance for the present framework.