AAO research

AAO Aug252009_02B2203: Nanowire Researcher’s Appeal Dismissed

AAO Aug252009_02B2203: Nanowire Researcher’s Appeal Dismissed

The AAO accepted scholarly authorship but rejected awards, memberships, media, judging, and major-contribution claims.

Decision snapshot

Decision detail

Source-backed value

Decision ID

Aug252009_02B2203

Disposition stated in the source

The appeal was dismissed after aggregate review found no sustained acclaim or top-of-field standing.

Source location

Final order, page 11

Academic honors and Sigma Xi membership did not meet the claimed criteria

The AAO found that academic recognition and scholarships were not awards for which the field’s most accomplished members compete. It also rejected membership in Sigma Xi, ACS, APS, and IEEE because the record did not show outstanding-achievement admission requirements judged by recognized experts.

Source: Aug252009_02B2203 page 3; Aug252009_02B2203 page 4.

Project listings and links were not published material about the petitioner

The AAO found that TND Newsletter listings and online access did not establish major-media coverage primarily about the petitioner. The record did not show that the listings discussed him or his work as required, and counsel’s assertions about the newsletter were unsupported.

Source: Aug252009_02B2203 page 5; Aug252009_02B2203 page 6.

Routine peer review and patent paperwork did not show major impact

The petitioner submitted manuscript-review requests and a thank-you message, but the AAO found no evidence that his peer review set him apart from the routine scientific review process. It also found that a patent application and letters did not establish field-wide impact; although the article was highly accessed and moderately cited, access did not show use and other articles had limited citations.

Source: Aug252009_02B2203 page 6; Aug252009_02B2203 page 7; Aug252009_02B2203 page 8; Aug252009_02B2203 page 9.

Scholarly authorship was accepted; the aggregate record still failed final merits

The AAO affirmed the scholarly-authorship finding. It then considered the evidence in aggregate, including association memberships, peer review, publications, citations, and peer praise. Comparing the record with more accomplished researchers, it found the petitioner had talent but had not shown sustained acclaim or standing among the small percentage at the top of the field.

Source: Aug252009_02B2203 page 10; Aug252009_02B2203 page 11.

Current framework and related reading

The decisions above are non-precedent assessments of particular records. Historical reasoning is identified as historical; consult current guidance for the present framework.

Primary sources reviewed for this article

Sources and corrections methodology