AAO research

Electrical Engineering Professor: Peer Review Counted, but Appeal Dismissed

Electrical Engineering Professor: Peer Review Counted, but Appeal Dismissed

The AAO credited peer review but found the other evidence insufficient to establish extraordinary ability.

Decision snapshot

Decision detail

Source-backed value

Decision ID

AUG122005_01B2203

Disposition stated in the source

The appeal is dismissed.

Source location

Final order, page 9

Peer review satisfied the judging criterion, but the decision described it as routine

The AAO did not withdraw the director’s finding that the petitioner’s peer-review work met the judging criterion. It cautioned that peer review is routine in science and said the evidence only minimally served to show acclaim. The decision therefore treats judging as met at the initial-criteria stage, with limited weight in the overall record.

Source: AUG122005_01B2203 page 4; AUG122005_01B2203 page 8.

Scholarships and a proposed research grant were not awards for achievement in the field

The AAO said academic scholarships and student awards were tied to training rather than achievement in the petitioner’s professional field. The record did not show that the NSF grant was actually issued; even if issued, the decision characterized research grants as funding future work rather than recognizing past achievement. The membership and published-material findings were not contested on appeal and were left undisturbed.

Source: AUG122005_01B2203 page 3.

Letters described promise and potential, but did not show established field impact

The letters described the wireless algorithms as promising and potentially useful, but the AAO found little evidence that companies or government agencies had expressed interest or implemented the work. The one reference describing current investigation at a Mexican university still spoke to potential applications. The book proposal had been declined and remained unpublished. The AAO concluded that the record did not show contributions of major significance already influencing the field.

Source: AUG122005_01B2203 page 5; AUG122005_01B2203 page 6; AUG122005_01B2203 page 7.

Nineteen articles and limited citations did not establish sufficient recognition

The petitioner had authored 19 journal or conference articles and submitted evidence of nine citing articles, but no article had more than five citations. The AAO considered publication expected in the research field and looked for evidence of the research community’s reaction. It found the citation record insufficient and was not persuaded that the publication record met the scholarly-authorship criterion.

Source: AUG122005_01B2203 page 7; AUG122005_01B2203 page 8.

Academic appointments and one conference session chair role were not leading or critical roles

The AAO said most committee and organizing responsibilities occurred after the filing date and could not establish eligibility at filing. It found that chairing one session at one conference was not a leading or critical role for the conference, and that an assistant research professor appointment did not by itself establish such a role for the university.

Source: AUG122005_01B2203 page 8; AUG122005_01B2203 page 9.

The AAO dismissed the appeal after finding no sustained acclaim

After reviewing the full record, the AAO concluded that the petitioner had not shown sustained national or international acclaim or that his achievements placed him among the small percentage at the top of his field. It dismissed the appeal. This is a 2005 nonprecedential decision and should be used as a case-specific illustration, not as a current universal rule.

Source: AUG122005_01B2203 page 2; AUG122005_01B2203 page 9.

Current framework and related reading

The decisions above are non-precedent assessments of particular records. Historical reasoning is identified as historical; consult current guidance for the present framework.

Primary sources reviewed for this article

Sources and corrections methodology