AAO research

AAO Software Developer Decision: Judging Accepted, Other Evidence Insufficient

AAO Software Developer Decision: Judging Accepted, Other Evidence Insufficient

Read the source-backed explanation of Aug092007_02B2203, the AAO's actual findings, and corrections to the previous article.

Decision snapshot

Decision detail

Source-backed value

Decision ID

Aug092007_02B2203

Disposition stated in the source

The appeal is dismissed.

Source location

Final order, page 11

Judging was accepted

In Aug092007_02B2203, the AAO dismissed a software developer's appeal. Page 4 withdraws the director's requirement that the petitioner have judged an internationally recognized competition. The AAO accepted the judging evidence; the previous article incorrectly presented that rejected requirement as a weakness in the petitioner's judging record.

Distinct questions for other criteria

Pages 3 to 4 address whether published material was about the petitioner. Pages 4 to 8 examine whether the software contribution had major significance, including the limits of search-result counts and uncorroborated testimonials. Page 9 discusses the article evidence, and pages 9 to 11 address the claimed leading or critical role.

The source does not support the previous article's allegation that the scholarly article evidence was falsified. That allegation has been removed.

Historical context

This 2007 decision predates Kazarian. Its discussion of publication counts and acclaim should be read as historical reasoning in this particular record, rather than a current numerical rule for scholarly articles.

Primary sources

Non-precedent decisions explain the records before the AAO. They are not binding precedent or predictions of another case.

How Extraordinary uses sources and corrections