AAO research

AAO Cardiologist Decision: Three Criteria, Unsuccessful Final Merits

AAO Cardiologist Decision: Three Criteria, Unsuccessful Final Merits

Read APR302018_01B2203: the AAO accepted judging, authorship, and a critical role, then dismissed the appeal after assessing final merits.

Decision snapshot

Decision detail

Source-backed value

Decision ID

APR302018_01B2203

Disposition stated in the source

The appeal was dismissed after the AAO found three initial criteria met but insufficient sustained acclaim at final merits.

Source location

Final order, page 5; Disposition context, page 3

The AAO added a third accepted criterion

The Director accepted judging and scholarly authorship but had not accepted the critical-role criterion in full because of the organization-reputation issue. The AAO found the additional reputation evidence sufficient and accepted the critical-role criterion. The AAO therefore proceeded with three criteria established.

Source: page 1, page 2, page 3.

What remained at final merits

The AAO then assessed the significance of the petitioner’s peer review, publication record, critical role, press coverage, and research influence. It found that the record did not demonstrate the sustained acclaim and standing at the top of the field required for this classification. It also identified an editorial-board appointment documented after filing.

Source: page 3, page 4, page 5.

Reserved criteria are not fresh rejections

The petitioner also asserted published material and contributions of major significance. After finding three criteria met, the AAO said it would discuss the remaining documentation in final merits. Its footnote identifies those two additional claims. The decision did not identify membership as an additional rejected criterion.

Source: page 3, page 4, page 5.

Correction to the earlier summary

The earlier summary presented membership, published material, and original contributions as a clean list of rejected initial criteria. That loses the distinction between criteria actually counted, claims not separately resolved at the threshold, and evidence weighed at final merits.

Source: page 2, page 3, page 4, page 5.

Read this historical decision in context

This is a non-precedent AAO decision about a particular record. Its historical reasoning is distinct from current guidance. For the present framework, read the initial evidence guide, the final merits guide, and the USCIS Policy Manual.

Primary sources

USCIS AAO decision APR302018_01B2203 (PDF, 5 pages)

Sources and corrections methodology