AAO research

AAO Medical Technology Researcher Decision: Two Criteria Were Insufficient

AAO Medical Technology Researcher Decision: Two Criteria Were Insufficient

Read the source-backed explanation of APR182018_02B2203, the AAO's actual findings, and corrections to the previous article.

Decision snapshot

Decision detail

Source-backed value

Decision ID

APR182018_02B2203

Disposition stated in the source

The appeal is dismissed.

Source location

Final order, page 5

Outcome and accepted evidence

APR182018_02B2203 dismissed a medical technology researcher's appeal. The AAO accepted judging on page 2 and authorship of scholarly articles on page 4. It found that the petitioner had not established at least three criteria.

Why the other evidence fell short

Pages 3 to 4 distinguish original work from a contribution of major significance. Claims about adoption and geographic use lacked adequate corroboration. Pages 4 to 5 address the employer's reputation and the petitioner's individual role separately; evidence about a different company did not establish the actual employer's reputation, and the letters did not sufficiently demonstrate a leading or critical role.

The membership issue was not pursued on appeal, according to the page 2 footnote. The prior article's allegation of falsified membership evidence was unsupported and has been removed.

What this decision supports

Identify the actual organization and corroborate the asserted impact. Do not treat evidence that a product exists, or a job title alone, as proof of every claimed criterion.

Primary sources

Non-precedent decisions explain the records before the AAO. They are not binding precedent or predictions of another case.

How Extraordinary uses sources and corrections