AAO research

AAO Aug082012_02B2203: Cinematographer Appeal Dismissed

AAO Aug082012_02B2203: Cinematographer Appeal Dismissed

Artistic display was accepted; published material, field impact, organizational role, and remaining evidence did not establish three criteria.

This was an EB-1A petition by a cinematographer, dismissed on appeal

The case concerned an immigrant petition for extraordinary ability in cinematography, filed November 5, 2010. It was not an adjustment-of-status application. The Director had found the published-material and artistic-display criteria met, but the AAO departed from the published-material finding, upheld artistic display, and concluded the petitioner lacked three qualifying criteria. The AAO dismissed the appeal.

Source: Aug082012_02B2203 page 2; Aug082012_02B2203 page 6; Aug082012_02B2203 page 10; Aug082012_02B2203 page 14.

The published-material evidence failed for different, item-specific reasons

A festival program was not material primarily about the cinematographer and his work. The three website photographs lacked the required author, title, and date because the criterion contemplated written or broadcast works. Reviews focused on films rather than the petitioner; the anonymous reader reviews were not authored by identified journalists. One short article was about him and his work, but lacked an author and evidence that its website qualified as professional or major media. The AAO also found no proof that the listed outlets had the required reach. It did not rule that personal websites are categorically disqualified under every criterion.

Source: Aug082012_02B2203 page 6; Aug082012_02B2203 page 7.

Artistic display remained an accepted criterion despite a weak program exhibit

The AAO found the incomplete festival-program pages did not themselves link a film to the festival, but noted other sufficient documentation and affirmed the Director’s finding that artistic display was met. The revised page should preserve this favorable criterion finding rather than claim that the program and all display evidence failed.

Source: Aug082012_02B2203 page 10.

Praise for skill and success on individual films did not prove field-wide contributions

The AAO required evidence of original contributions already realized and of major significance to the field as a whole. Letters praising talent, projects, and individual film success did not provide specific examples or corroboration showing the cinematographer had significantly impacted the field. Success on a single film or performing the ordinary duties of the occupation did not establish field-wide impact in this record. The AAO treated expert letters as evidence to evaluate, not presumptive proof.

Source: Aug082012_02B2203 page 8; Aug082012_02B2203 page 9; Aug082012_02B2203 page 10.

Production work was not enough to establish a leading or critical role for an organization

The AAO distinguished a role on an individual film or project from a role for an organization or establishment as a whole. It found that letters lacked detail about the petitioner’s place in the organizational hierarchy, duties, or impact on the organization’s activities; asserted reputation and project success were not independently substantiated. It also found that using a company’s equipment did not by itself make a customer a leader or critical contributor to that company.

Source: Aug082012_02B2203 page 11; Aug082012_02B2203 page 12.

Other criteria and the final order should be described without changing their disposition

The AAO treated the awards and membership issues as abandoned on appeal; the petitioner did not contest the Director’s adverse findings. It found no comparative earnings evidence for high salary and treated that issue as abandoned, and it likewise found no qualifying commercial-success evidence on appeal. The final conclusion was that the petitioner had not met at least three criteria; the appeal was dismissed. These are separate grounds and should not be reduced to the published-material issue alone.

Source: Aug082012_02B2203 page 5; Aug082012_02B2203 page 13; Aug082012_02B2203 page 14.

Current framework and related reading

The decisions above are non-precedent assessments of particular records. Historical reasoning is identified as historical; consult current guidance for the present framework.

Primary sources reviewed for this article

Sources and corrections methodology