AAO research

EB-1A Case Study: AUG222018_01B2203

EB-1A Case Study: AUG222018_01B2203

Read the corrected case study for AUG222018_01B2203, with the original disposition, attributed source passages, and links to the USCIS decision.

Corrected source reading

The earlier article overstated the legal requirements or the implications of this record. This replacement separates the document’s findings from a general rule. Read the attributed passages and the complete decision before drawing a lesson for another case.

Disposition in the source

The appeal is dismissed.

Final order, page 5.

Passages from the original record

. Matter ofM -B-T-A-S- at 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(h)(3) sets forth a multi-part analysis. First, a petitioner can demonstrate sustained acclaim and the recognition of his or her achievements in the field through a one-time achievement (that is, a major, internationally recognized award). If that petitioner does not submit this evidence, then he or she must provide sufficient qualifying documentation that meets at least three of the ten categories listed at 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(h)(3)(i)- (x) (including items such as awards, published material in certain media, and scholarly articles). Satisfaction of at least three criteria, however, does not, in and of itself, establish eligibility for this classification. See Kazarian v. USCIS, 596 F .3d 1115 (9th Cir. 2010) (d iscussing a two-part review where the documentation is first counted and then, if fulfilling the required number of criteria, considered in the context of a final merits determination); see also Visinscaia v. Beers, 4 F. Supp. 3d 126, 131-32 (D.D.C. 2013); […]

Original USCIS decision AUG222018_01B2203, page 2. Ellipses mark an excerpt; read the full page for the surrounding discussion.

evidence, to determine whether the fact to be proven is -probably true"). Accordingly, where a petitioner submits qualifying evidence under at least three criteria, we will determine whether the totality of the record shows sustained national or international acclaim and demonstrates that the individual is among the small percentage at the very top of the field of endeavor. II. ANALYSIS The Director found that the Beneficiary, a ballet dancer and instructor, met one of the evidentiary criteria at 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(h)(3)(i)-(x), . relating to the artistic display of his work. On appeal, the Petitioner asserts that the Beneficiary also meets the evidentiary criteria concerning prizes and awards, media about him and his work, and his role for organizations with a distinguished reputation. After reviewing all of the evidence in the record, we agree that it establishes that the Beneficiary's work has been displayed at artistic exhibitions, but do not find that he meets the requisite three evidentiary criteria. Documentation of the individual's receipt of lesser nationally or internationally recognized prizes or awards for excellence in the field of endeavor. […]

Original USCIS decision AUG222018_01B2203, page 2. Ellipses mark an excerpt; read the full page for the surrounding discussion.

The Petitioner also asserts on appeal that the advisory opinion it obtained for purposes of the previous nonimmigrant petition for 0-1 visa status for the Beneficiary should be considered as a prize or award. However, this determination by the was not made in the course of any sort of competition or selection; it is an opinion letter created for purposes of the nonimmigrant visa petition only, and it is limited to the Beneficiary's eligibility for 0-1 visa status. Therefore, we do not find that it is a prize or award which qualifies under this criterion. Accordingly, this criterion has not been met. Published material about the individual in professional or major trade publications or other major media, relating to the alien's work in the field for which classification is sought. Such evidence shall include the title, date, and author of the material, and any necessary translation. 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(h)(3)(iii) The Petitioner submitted several materials under this criterion, including an interview of the Beneficiary that appeared in the January/February 2015 issue of , a review of the Petitioner's performance of […]

Original USCIS decision AUG222018_01B2203, page 3. Ellipses mark an excerpt; read the full page for the surrounding discussion.

Questions for reading this decision

Identify which statements describe the petitioner’s position, the director’s reasoning, and the AAO’s conclusions. The number of claims discussed in a particular case is not the number of regulatory categories. A case’s outcome does not make every listed category a requirement in every petition.

For the current framework, read the initial evidence guide and the relevant criterion guide. Distinguish the initial categories from final merits. Historical non-precedent reasoning must be read in context; a motion, remand, or dismissed appeal does not by itself establish every underlying factual proposition.

Primary sources

Complete USCIS AAO decision AUG222018_01B2203 (PDF)

Current USCIS Policy Manual: Extraordinary Ability