AAO research
Read the corrected case study for APR302020_01B2203, with the original disposition, attributed source passages, and links to the USCIS decision.
Corrected source reading
The earlier article overstated the legal requirements or the implications of this record. This replacement separates the document’s findings from a general rule. Read the attributed passages and the complete decision before drawing a lesson for another case.
Disposition in the source
The appeal is dismissed.
Passages from the original record
acclaim and the recognition of his or her achievements in the field through a one-time achievement (that is, a major, internationally recognized award). If that petitioner does not submit this evidence, then he or she must provide sufficient qualifying documentation that meets at least three of the ten categories listed at 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(h)(3)(i) - (x) (including items such as awards, published material in certain media, and scholarly articles). The regulation at 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(5)(4) allows a petitioner to submit comparable material if he or she is able to demonstrate that the standards at 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(h)(3)(i)-)(x) do not readily apply to the individual's occupation. Where a petitioner meets these initial evidence requirements, we then consider the totality of the material provided in a final merits determination and assess whether the record shows sustained national or international acclaim and demonstrates that the individual is among the small percentage at the very top of the field of endeavor. […]
Original USCIS decision APR302020_01B2203, page 2. Ellipses mark an excerpt; read the full page for the surrounding discussion.
The Petitioner indicated that he is owner and president of,___ ______ ___, in lcanada. Because the Director found that the Petitioner did not establish that he received a major, internationally recognized award under the regulation at 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(h)(3), he must satisfy at least three of the alternate regulatory criteria at 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(h)(3)(i)-(x). On appeal, the Petitioner indicated on his Form I-290B, Notice of Appeal or Motion, and accompanying letter that he would be filing a brief and additional evidence to our office within 30 days. However, as of the date of this decision, we have received nothing further. Accordingly, the record is considered complete as it now stands. In denying the petition, the Director determined that the Petitioner fulfilled only two of the initial evidentiary criteria, awards at 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(h)(3)(i) and published material at 8 C.F.R. § 204.5(h)(3)(iii). On his Form I-290B, the Petitioner generally asserts that he received a major, internationally recognized award and, in the alternative, meets at least three criteria. After reviewing all of the evidence in the record, we conclude […]
Original USCIS decision APR302020_01B2203, page 2. Ellipses mark an excerpt; read the full page for the surrounding discussion.
Director found that the Petitioner did not establish that the dressage score award enjoyed the same level of attention or stature similar to other major, internationally recognized awards, such as the Nobel Prize, Pulitzer Prize, the Academy Award, and an Olympic Medal. 1 In addition, the Director indicated that the "Olympics include equestrian events such as dressage; however, the evidence in the record I I does not place the on the same level as an Olympic event." Further, the Director cited to the official website of the U.S. Equestrian Federation and determined that "the website does not appear to I I accord the with a level of recognition as one of the top events for the sport on par with the Olympics or others such global events." Based on Congress' intent to restrict this category to "that small percentage of individuals who have risen to the very top of their field of endeavor," the regulation permitting eligibility based on a one time achievement must be interpreted very narrowly, with only a small handful of awards qualifying as major, internationally recognized […]
Original USCIS decision APR302020_01B2203, page 3. Ellipses mark an excerpt; read the full page for the surrounding discussion.
Questions for reading this decision
Identify which statements describe the petitioner’s position, the director’s reasoning, and the AAO’s conclusions. The number of claims discussed in a particular case is not the number of regulatory categories. A case’s outcome does not make every listed category a requirement in every petition.
For the current framework, read the initial evidence guide and the relevant criterion guide. Distinguish the initial categories from final merits. Historical non-precedent reasoning must be read in context; a motion, remand, or dismissed appeal does not by itself establish every underlying factual proposition.