AAO research

AAO APR052005_02B2203: Model and Actress Wins EB-1A

AAO APR052005_02B2203: Model and Actress Wins EB-1A

A 2005 approval accepted media coverage, high modeling pay, and film success while rejecting reliance on O-1 approval as proof of EB-1A eligibility.

Modeling and acting were considered together in this record

The petitioner proposed work as a fashion model. The AAO considered her acting achievements as well because the record showed that she continued both kinds of work at the highest national level. It nevertheless rejected counsel’s claim that her arts O-1 approval itself proved EB-1A eligibility: the arts nonimmigrant standard and the immigrant classification had to be assessed under their own rules.

Source: APR052005_02B2203 page 2.

Three categories were expressly accepted

The AAO accepted published material because some articles appeared in nationally distributed publications. It accepted high remuneration based on approximately $5,000 for an eight-hour modeling day, less a $1,050 agent commission, compared with the submitted hourly model wage. The AAO acknowledged limits in the comparison but found the disparity sufficient in this record. These figures describe this petitioner, not a minimum fee for models.

Source: APR052005_02B2203 page 3.

Film receipts supported commercial success, not an award finding

The AAO accepted commercial success based on a film’s box-office results and promotional evidence identifying the petitioner’s prominent role. A later film supported continued work but did not establish eligibility at filing. The AAO did not need to decide leading or critical role because the requisite three categories were met. It expressly withdrew the denial, sustained the appeal, and approved the petition.

Source: APR052005_02B2203 page 4.

Current framework and related reading

The decisions above are non-precedent assessments of particular records. Historical reasoning is identified as historical; consult current guidance for the present framework.

Primary sources reviewed for this article

Sources and corrections methodology