AAO research

Television Work and EB-1A Leading-Role Evidence

Television Work and EB-1A Leading-Role Evidence

The AAO found that a comedian’s role evidence was insufficient and the record did not establish that the television programs were qualifying organizations.

This decision addressed a specific television comedian’s record

The petitioner was an Argentine comedian who relied on work in television programs, along with other evidence. The AAO evaluated both whether his role was leading or critical and whether the programs met the regulation’s “organizations or establishments” language. It did not announce that all television productions are categorically disqualified.

Source: APR102025_06B2203 page 1; APR102025_06B2203 page 7; APR102025_06B2203 page 8.

The record lacked detail about the petitioner’s role in the programs

Letters described the petitioner as a partner, an essential part, or a key contributor, but the AAO found they did not provide specific details such as the number of episodes, airtime, the importance of his characters relative to other performers, or corroborating ratings evidence. The decision said that without further support it could not find the claimed leading or critical role for those programs.

Source: APR102025_06B2203 page 7; APR102025_06B2203 page 8.

The AAO separately found these shows were not organizations or establishments on this record

The petitioner argued that he had performed a leading or critical role for named television programs. The AAO said that even if it assumed a qualifying role, which it did not, the criterion also required an organization or establishment. Applying the ordinary meanings of those terms and citing Sarin v. United States, it concluded this petitioner had not established that his television shows constituted organizations or establishments. That is the decision’s reasoning in this case; the source does not establish the draft’s universal claim that television shows are simply “individual production events,” or that an enduring corporate structure, business license, or membership list is invariably required.

Source: APR102025_06B2203 page 8.

The result was dismissal for failure to meet three initial criteria

The AAO found the petitioner met the artistic-display criterion, but not the awards, membership, published-material, original-contributions, role, salary, or commercial-success criteria. Because fewer than three criteria were established, it said a formal final-merits determination under Kazarian was unnecessary and reserved that issue. It nevertheless separately stated that aggregate review did not support the required acclaim. Do not describe the ruling as a final-merits denial.

Source: APR102025_06B2203 page 1; APR102025_06B2203 page 10; APR102025_06B2203 page 11.

Treat this as a nonprecedent example, not a checklist for every production

This decision supports a practical evidentiary lesson: document what the person did, why the role mattered compared with others, and the distinguished reputation of the relevant organization or establishment. It does not prescribe business filings, org charts, executive lists, or other specific documents as mandatory, and it does not decide every possible studio, broadcaster, theater, or production-company fact pattern. Its holding is tied to the record before the AAO.

Source: APR102025_06B2203 page 7; APR102025_06B2203 page 8.

Current framework and related reading

The decisions above are non-precedent assessments of particular records. Historical reasoning is identified as historical; consult current guidance for the present framework.

Primary sources reviewed for this article

Sources and corrections methodology