AAO research

AAO Aug062010_03B2203: Athletic Trainer Evidence Review

AAO Aug062010_03B2203: Athletic Trainer Evidence Review

The AAO rejected the athletic trainer’s high-salary claim because the W-2 and contract conflicted, and found fewer than three criteria.

The decision concerns a professional baseball athletic trainer

The petitioner sought EB-1A classification in athletics as an athletic trainer. The AAO dismissed the appeal after finding the evidence insufficient under the claimed criteria and concluded, including in the aggregate, that the record did not show sustained acclaim or top-of-field standing.

Source: Aug062010_03B2203 page 3; Aug062010_03B2203 page 25; Aug062010_03B2203 page 27.

The supplied summary incorrectly says high salary was accepted

The director initially found the petitioner had not met the salary criterion, then found it met on motion after reviewing a W-2 showing $152,757.26. The AAO withdrew that favorable finding because the W-2 conflicted sharply with the contract showing $43,000 salary plus a $5,400 housing stipend, and the record did not explain the difference or show that other compensation was significantly high among athletic trainers. The AAO therefore found the criterion unmet.

Source: Aug062010_03B2203 page 23.

The role evidence did not establish a qualifying leading or critical role

The record described the petitioner as an assistant athletic trainer and massage therapist and did not show where he fit in the major-league team hierarchy. The AAO acknowledged a leading or critical role for a minor-league team but found no evidence that team had a distinguished reputation. It also found insufficient evidence about the petitioner’s place among the staff at the major-league team and special events. The decision therefore did not find this criterion established.

Source: Aug062010_03B2203 page 19; Aug062010_03B2203 page 21.

The published-material record had translation, identification, timing, and outlet gaps

Foreign-language articles had uncertified, difficult-to-understand translations, often without the date, author, or publication identified. The record lacked circulation or distribution evidence. A 2007 Los Angeles Times article was not primarily about the petitioner, and a later article submitted on appeal postdated the petition filing; the AAO also described that article as primarily about the team’s season goals and mentioning the petitioner only briefly. The decision did not say that every cited piece failed solely because it lacked circulation data.

Source: Aug062010_03B2203 page 3; Aug062010_03B2203 page 11; Aug062010_03B2203 page 13.

The Japanese massage and acupuncture techniques were not shown to be original contributions of major significance

The AAO found the evidence showed the petitioner applied traditional Japanese massage and acupuncture techniques but did not show he developed them, influenced athletic training across the field, or that other teams adopted them. A newspaper article did not establish his causal contribution; the record did not show that other teams emulated the techniques. The decision distinguished a skillful job performance or a technique that is uncommon locally from an original contribution of major significance to the field.

Source: Aug062010_03B2203 page 15; Aug062010_03B2203 page 17; Aug062010_03B2203 page 19.

The record did not establish qualifying association membership

The AAO noted the lack of documentation of the petitioner’s memberships and of the associations’ membership requirements; counsel did not contest the director’s findings on appeal. This was a separate criterion from role or employment.

Source: Aug062010_03B2203 page 11.

The AAO found no three criteria and assessed final merits in the aggregate

The decision’s summary states that the petitioner had not submitted the required evidence under at least three categories. It nevertheless conducted final-merits analysis and found the evidence insufficient in the aggregate. The source’s final order dismissed the appeal. It does not support the draft’s statement that high salary was the sole exception.

Source: Aug062010_03B2203 page 25; Aug062010_03B2203 page 27.

This nonprecedent case is not a universal evidentiary checklist

The decision evaluates one record, occupation, employer, and filing date. Its specific findings may illustrate the need to connect evidence to each criterion, but should not be converted into blanket rules for all athletic trainers, sports organizations, or compensation records.

Source: Aug062010_03B2203 page 3; Aug062010_03B2203 page 25; Aug062010_03B2203 page 27.

Current framework and related reading

The decisions above are non-precedent assessments of particular records. Historical reasoning is identified as historical; consult current guidance for the present framework.

Primary sources reviewed for this article

Sources and corrections methodology