AAO research
The AAO found scholarly authorship met, but only one of the required three criteria.
Decision snapshot
Decision detail | Source-backed value |
|---|---|
Decision ID | Dec072011_02B2203 |
Disposition stated in the source | The appeal is dismissed. |
Source location |
The director’s uncertain finding on judging was reviewed de novo and reversed
The director’s decision was unclear about whether judging was met, so the AAO reviewed it de novo. The petitioner submitted a self-created list of seven papers and reproduced emails requesting reviews, but did not submit primary evidence that he actually completed reviews. The AAO found that an invitation or request alone was not participation as a judge. It noted that primary evidence could have been obtained from the review systems described in the emails.
Source: Dec072011_02B2203 page 5; Dec072011_02B2203 page 6; Dec072011_02B2203 page 7; Dec072011_02B2203 page 8.
The original-contributions finding by the director was withdrawn
The director had found original contributions met, but the AAO withdrew that finding. Letters described the petitioner’s work on deception-detection projects and Google projects without specific evidence of substantial effect on the field. Much of the claimed impact was prospective; the record did not show implementation or present field-wide influence. Two independent citations were documented, and counsel’s higher citation counts were unsupported or post-filing. Provisional patent applications also did not establish authorship, ownership, granted patents, or field impact.
Source: Dec072011_02B2203 page 8; Dec072011_02B2203 page 9; Dec072011_02B2203 page 10; Dec072011_02B2203 page 11; Dec072011_02B2203 page 12; Dec072011_02B2203 page 13.
Scholarly authorship was the sole criterion the AAO found met
The AAO expressly found that evidence established the plain-language authorship criterion for scholarly articles. It stated that the record showed nine papers and conference presentations; it did not say that this alone proved extraordinary ability. The page should keep this distinction clear: meeting the threshold criterion and satisfying final merits are separate steps.
Source: Dec072011_02B2203 page 13; Dec072011_02B2203 page 18; Dec072011_02B2203 page 19.
The leading-role claim was abandoned on appeal
The director had found leading or critical role unmet. Counsel did not contest that finding or offer additional argument, so the AAO treated the issue as abandoned and concluded the petitioner failed to establish the criterion.
Source: Dec072011_02B2203 page 13; Dec072011_02B2203 page 14.
The salary finding was withdrawn because the W-2 post-dated filing and comparison was inadequate
The director had found high salary met using a 2008 W-2 and a salary.com figure. The petition had been filed December 31, 2007, so the AAO held 2008 earnings could not establish eligibility at filing. It also found the figure was for entry-level Level I salary and showed only a 90th percentile amount; higher-level benchmarks were above the petitioner’s earnings, and the W-2 did not establish which amounts were salary versus other compensation. The AAO withdrew the director’s favorable finding.
Source: Dec072011_02B2203 page 14; Dec072011_02B2203 page 15; Dec072011_02B2203 page 16; Dec072011_02B2203 page 17.
Published-material and leading-role arguments were abandoned, not evaluated as met
For published material, the director had found the criterion unmet and the petitioner did not contest it on appeal; the AAO treated it as abandoned. The same occurred for leading or critical role. This differs from authorship, which the AAO found met, and from judging, contributions, and high salary, where the AAO conducted review and found the criteria unmet.
Source: Dec072011_02B2203 page 5; Dec072011_02B2203 page 13; Dec072011_02B2203 page 14.
The appeal was dismissed after one criterion was met and final merits failed
The AAO found only the scholarly-authorship criterion met, short of the required three. It also conducted final merits and found the petitioner’s scholarly output, limited citations, routine research, and occasional peer review did not demonstrate sustained acclaim or top-of-field standing. It dismissed the appeal. This 2011 AAO decision is nonprecedential and case-specific.
Source: Dec072011_02B2203 page 17; Dec072011_02B2203 page 18; Dec072011_02B2203 page 19; Dec072011_02B2203 page 20.
Current framework and related reading
The decisions above are non-precedent assessments of particular records. Historical reasoning is identified as historical; consult current guidance for the present framework.