AAO research

Chemistry Researcher: Peer Review and Authorship Met, but Not Three Criteria

Chemistry Researcher: Peer Review and Authorship Met, but Not Three Criteria

The AAO found judging and scholarly authorship met, but original contributions lacked demonstrated major field-wide significance.

Decision snapshot

Decision detail

Source-backed value

Decision ID

Aug192010_02B2203

Disposition stated in the source

The appeal is dismissed.

Source location

Final order, page 18

The AAO found judging and scholarly authorship met

The petitioner was a chemistry researcher. The AAO withdrew the director’s denial on judging and found that documented peer reviews for three journals met the plain-language judging criterion. It also found that the petitioner documented authorship of 24 scholarly articles in qualifying publications. These were the only two threshold criteria established, short of the required three.

Source: Aug192010_02B2203 page 5; Aug192010_02B2203 page 14.

Original research and favorable letters did not establish major significance

The AAO accepted that the petitioner produced original chemistry and nanotube research but found the evidence did not demonstrate major significance to the field as a whole. Letters described potential applications, future patents, promise, and work within collaborators’ projects; they did not show sufficiently broad present implementation or impact. The decision noted examples of independent use/citations but found they did not establish major significance.

Source: Aug192010_02B2203 page 5; Aug192010_02B2203 page 8; Aug192010_02B2203 page 9; Aug192010_02B2203 page 10; Aug192010_02B2203 page 11; Aug192010_02B2203 page 12.

Citation evidence showed some interest, but not field-wide impact at threshold review

The record showed 24 articles cited 75 times in aggregate, including self-citations. The AAO noted that 20 articles had five or fewer citations, seven had none, and the most-cited article had nine. It found this record did not show that the petitioner’s work significantly contributed to the field for the original-contributions criterion.

Source: Aug192010_02B2203 page 13.

Authorship met the plain-language criterion despite the director’s impact-based rationale

The AAO rejected the director’s use of citation impact as a reason to deny authorship. It found the petitioner documented authorship of scholarly articles in professional publications and held the plain-language authorship criterion met. It later considered citation impact in final merits.

Source: Aug192010_02B2203 page 13; Aug192010_02B2203 page 14.

Two criteria met did not demonstrate sustained acclaim or top-of-field standing

In final merits, the AAO considered peer review, authorship and citation history and compared the record with the claimed level of acclaim. It found that 24 authored articles, 75 citations with modest per-article counts, and the documented reviewing activity did not establish sustained acclaim or that the petitioner was among the small percentage at the very top. It also noted that research letters came from people who had worked with or interacted with the petitioner.

Source: Aug192010_02B2203 page 14; Aug192010_02B2203 page 15; Aug192010_02B2203 page 16; Aug192010_02B2203 page 17.

The AAO dismissed the appeal

The petitioner did not establish the required three criteria and also failed to demonstrate sustained national or international acclaim or top-of-field standing. The AAO dismissed the appeal. Present this as a case-specific AAO decision and do not turn its evidentiary assessment into a universal citation-count threshold.

Source: Aug192010_02B2203 page 17; Aug192010_02B2203 page 18.

Current framework and related reading

The decisions above are non-precedent assessments of particular records. Historical reasoning is identified as historical; consult current guidance for the present framework.

Primary sources reviewed for this article

Sources and corrections methodology