AAO research

Bioengineering Researcher: Judging and Authorship Met, but Major Impact Was Not Shown

Bioengineering Researcher: Judging and Authorship Met, but Major Impact Was Not Shown

The AAO found judging and scholarly authorship met but rejected original contributions and a leading or critical role.

Decision snapshot

Decision detail

Source-backed value

Decision ID

Aug152012_03B2203

Disposition stated in the source

The appeal is dismissed.

Source location

Final order, page 13

The AAO found two criteria met, short of the required three

On appeal, the AAO withdrew the director’s adverse findings on judging and scholarly authorship and found the petitioner minimally met those criteria. It rejected original contributions and leading/critical role. Awards, membership, and published material were treated as abandoned because counsel did not challenge the director’s findings on appeal. Thus the petitioner did not meet the required three criteria.

Source: Aug152012_03B2203 page 2; Aug152012_03B2203 page 4; Aug152012_03B2203 page 9; Aug152012_03B2203 page 10; Aug152012_03B2203 page 12; Aug152012_03B2203 page 13.

Citation counts alone did not show major significance

The record showed 16 scholarly and scientific articles with 128 citations including 15 self-citations, or 113 independent citations. One article had 28 independent citations; 12 articles had fewer than ten independent citations, including four with none. The AAO found no additional documentary evidence that the work was unusually influential or substantially changed the field. It excluded citations arising after filing. These observations are case-specific and do not create a fixed citation threshold.

Source: Aug152012_03B2203 page 5.

Conference presentations and a patent did not prove field-wide impact

The petitioner presented research at scientific conferences and documented a patent. The AAO found no evidence that the presentations influenced the field beyond their audiences, and the patent certificate did not identify its issuing authority. It also explained that a patent can recognize originality without demonstrating major significance to the field; significance is assessed case by case.

Source: Aug152012_03B2203 page 5; Aug152012_03B2203 page 6.

Solicited letters described potential impact more than demonstrated current influence

The AAO found the letters relied on selected materials supplied by the petitioner, offered general praise, and did not provide detailed evidence of major impact. Many statements described future benefits and possible clinical applications. The AAO acknowledged originality and some notice of the work, but found no evidence the field was widely applying the results at filing.

Source: Aug152012_03B2203 page 6; Aug152012_03B2203 page 7; Aug152012_03B2203 page 8; Aug152012_03B2203 page 9.

Research roles at respected institutions were not shown to be leading or critical

The AAO considered research roles at Tsinghua University and departments at USC and UCLA, but found the letters did not explain the petitioner’s position in the organizations’ hierarchies, differentiate him from other researchers, or show he was responsible for their success or standing. The record also lacked documentary evidence establishing the claimed organizations’ distinguished reputations for this criterion. The AAO dismissed the appeal.

Source: Aug152012_03B2203 page 10; Aug152012_03B2203 page 11; Aug152012_03B2203 page 12; Aug152012_03B2203 page 13.

Current framework and related reading

The decisions above are non-precedent assessments of particular records. Historical reasoning is identified as historical; consult current guidance for the present framework.

Primary sources reviewed for this article

Sources and corrections methodology