AAO research

2009 Arts EB-1A Appeal: RFE Delivery Dispute and Summary Dismissal

2009 Arts EB-1A Appeal: RFE Delivery Dispute and Summary Dismissal

The RFE reached the supplied address, but forwarding failed. The AAO dismissed when the appeal did not address the Director's substantive evidence findings.

Decision snapshot

Decision detail

Source-backed value

Decision ID

Aug062009_01B2203

Disposition stated in the source

Appeal summarily dismissed for failure to identify specific error or address the substantive denial findings.

Source location

Final order, page 3

The RFE reached the address provided on the petition

The arts petitioner did not respond to an April 2008 RFE. On appeal he acknowledged that it reached the mailing address he had supplied, but said a later forwarding attempt did not reach his home. The AAO found that the Director complied with service requirements and distinguished later forwarding problems from agency error.

Source: page 2, page 3.

The original denial considered actual evidence

The AAO explained that denial was based on the record and the extraordinary-ability claim, rather than primarily on the absent RFE response. It specifically identified the Director's discussion of an RSA Student Design Award and deficiencies under the lesser-awards category. The prior article's assertion that no qualifying-category evidence had been presented erased that actual record.

Source: page 3.

The appeal did not supply a substantive answer

The AAO stated that full appellate consideration of a rebuttal could address the request to reopen, but no arguments or evidence answering the regulatory findings accompanied the appeal. Because the petitioner did not identify specific legal or factual error, it summarily dismissed. The ruling does not mean that failure of one criterion automatically triggers summary dismissal.

Source: page 3.

Read this historical decision in context

This is a non-precedent AAO decision about a particular record. Its historical reasoning is distinct from current guidance. For the present framework, read the initial evidence guide, the final merits guide, and the USCIS Policy Manual.

Primary sources

USCIS AAO decision Aug062009_01B2203 (PDF, 3 pages)

Sources and corrections methodology